Executive Director Evaluation Form Template
Give your board a structured process for evaluating the executive director's performance objectively.
Evaluating an executive director's performance is one of the most important responsibilities a nonprofit or organizational board has, and one of the hardest to do well. Without a structured process, evaluations become subjective, inconsistent, or conflict-prone. Board members assess different things with different weightings, and the ED has no clear criteria to understand how they're being measured.
A Typeform executive director evaluation form gives the board a consistent framework. Each evaluator works through the same categories, from leadership and financial stewardship to stakeholder relationships and program outcomes, rating and commenting on each one. Conditional logic can prompt follow-up questions when a dimension is rated particularly high or low. Aggregate results show where there's alignment and where board members see things differently.
Customize the form to reflect your organization's strategic priorities and the criteria outlined in the ED's employment agreement. Share it with board members at the scheduled review period and use the aggregated responses as the foundation for the evaluation conversation.
An executive director evaluation form is a structured tool used by a board of directors to assess the performance of their executive director. It evaluates leadership, financial management, program results, stakeholder relationships, and strategic progress against defined goals.
A consistent, criteria-based evaluation is fairer for the ED and more useful for the board. It ensures every board member is assessing the same dimensions, produces a documented record of the review, and gives the ED clear feedback tied to specific performance areas rather than general impressions.
Structure the evaluation around the core responsibilities of the role:
- Leadership and organizational culture
- Financial management and fiduciary responsibility
- Program outcomes and mission advancement
- Board relations and communication
- External stakeholder and donor relationships
- Staff development and team effectiveness
- Strategic planning and goal achievement
- Overall performance rating and summary comments
Collect all board member evaluations through the same form. The aggregated results in Typeform show average ratings for each dimension and all written comments in one place, making it straightforward to identify where the board has consensus and where perspectives diverge before the formal evaluation meeting.
Present the aggregated quantitative scores alongside a summary of key themes from written comments. Use the areas of strong performance and areas for development as the structure for the conversation. Having documented responses from all board members rather than impressions from a few makes the discussion more objective and reduces the potential for the review to feel personal.
Get inspired by relevant templates and categories
3200+ Templates, 300+ Integrations
With Typeform, you can customize everything
Change text, colors, and even logos to match the look and feel of your brand. Then embed forms smoothly onto web and email.
Make forms feel effortless to fill out. Pace questions, call people by their name, and adapt the flow based on the data they share.
Stay efficient by connecting forms to your workflow. Typeform integrates with 300+ tools including Slack, Zapier, and HubSpot.
